Father Benedict Bayer established the parish in 1849
By: Johanna Elattar
St. Ann’s Church and School have been integral to the Hornell community for over a century and a half, embodying a legacy of faith, education, and service.
The roots of St. Ann’s Church trace back to 1843, when Father Benedict Bayer organized the parish and celebrated the first Mass in a private home near Webb’s Crossing. Officially established in 1849, the parish dedicated its first church building on April 11, 1869. The current church, constructed in the French Gothic Revival style, was completed in 1889 and stands as a testament to the community’s enduring faith.
In 1863, Father Michael Creedan founded St. Ann School, marking the beginning of Catholic education in Hornell. The school moved into a new building in 1890, accommodating up to 300 students. Over the years, the school adapted to the community’s needs, including the addition of a new wing in 1962. Despite its closure in 2012 due to financial difficulties, St. Ann School’s legacy continues to influence the community.
Constructed between 1910 and 1912, the St. Ann’s Federation Building served as a community center, featuring a large auditorium and dance hall. Designed by architect Otis Dockstader, the building is a notable example of Neoclassical architecture and was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2001.
In 2013, St. Ann’s Academy was established, continuing the mission of Catholic education in Hornell. Serving students from pre-kindergarten through grade 6, the academy focuses on academic excellence and spiritual development. With a student-teacher ratio of 13:1 and a commitment to inclusivity, St. Ann’s Academy remains a vital part of the community.
St. Ann’s Church and School have been more than just institutions; they have been the heartbeat of Hornell, shaping generations of individuals committed to faith, education, and service. Their enduring presence continues to inspire and uplift the community, standing as a testament to the power of faith and education in shaping a vibrant and resilient community.
Johanna Elattar is a journalist and author whose work bridges personal narrative and investigative insight. Based in Hornell, NY, she writes for the Hornell Sun and Wellsville Sun, covering local stories, social justice, and national issues. Her reporting has been recognized internationally, her work is featured in the forthcoming 4th edition of Race & Racisms (Oxford University Press, 2026). Beyond journalism, Johanna is the author of the upcoming novella Hollow Echo and regularly explores complex topics with honesty, clarity, and depth, giving voice to overlooked communities and nuanced stories. You can reach her anytime, americangrrl70@gmail.com
